THE BEST READS OF 2004

 

Every year we ask our customers to report their favorite – and least favorite – reads of the year. Here are the reports we got for 2004. If you want to contribute your own picks, just email us. We’ll add yours to the list.

 

 

Without question, my favorite book of the year is Bel Canto by Ann
Patchett.  The book is superbly written with wonderful characters.  Truly
an exceptional book.  I have since read all her other books, including
Truth & Beauty, which describes a close friendship and Patchett's own
journey as a writer.  –Lee Eaton

 

Here are a few of the books I enjoyed reading this year:

The Time Traveler’s Wife by Audrey Niffenegger

The Secret Life of Bees by Sue Monk Kidd

The Last Juror by John Grisham

The Five People You Meet in Heaven by Mitch Albom

Myra Sims by Janis Owens (Her first book is My Brother Michael)

The Schooling of Claybird Catts by Janis Owens

Olive’s Ocean (juvenile lit book I reviewed)

Because of Winn Dixie (juvenile lit book I reviewed)

One Foot in Eden by Ron Rash (my favorite this year)

The Monk Downstairs by Tim Farrington

The Queen of the Big Time by Andriana Trigiani

Swan Place by Augusta Trobaugh  -Lou Fuller, South Pittsburg, Tennessee

 

 

The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini was the book DH (dear husband) and I discussed the most, and choose as our favorite for 2004.  Definitely not for the faint of heart, this is a story of love and hatred in modern Afghanistan, and proves to be an important novel at this point in history.  Happy New Year to all.  -Menelle Weiss 

 

Fiction--Zafon's "Shadow of the Wind", far and away.  Sally would agree, though she'd also nominate "Shantaram" by Gregory David Roberts.    And Richard Price's "Samaritan,"  new in paperback.  For nonfiction, it's a tie between Edward Conlon's "Blue Blood" and Robert Kurson's "Shadow Divers."  For kids, "Sea of Trolls" by Nancy Farmer and "Bucking the Sarge" by Christopher Paul Curtis are the best YA I've read in years.  –Frazer Dobson, Charlotte, NC

 

 

I attended the book signing for Fannie Flagg on Monday.  I appreciate very much your getting the three books that I requested.  Even though I did not get to have my book signed in person, I am excited that you made the extra effort to get the books and have her sign them for me.  It was great being caught up in the excitement that this book signing created.  Thank you for bringing such distinguished authors to Montgomery.  I have attended several signings at Capitol and I look forward to the next one.
I enjoy reading very much and set a goal for myself for this year to read five books a month.  I enjoy reading a variety of books from best sellers to books by regional authors. One of my favorites was a very short book by Corky Pugh, a fellow Monroe Countian, called "Friends and Family."  It is about his childhood -learning to hunt and fish - and the special people in his life who taught him how to hunt and fish and enjoy the simple things in life.  How fitting that Corky is now the director of the Game and Fish Commission for the state of Alabama.  I am delighted that Corky has the opportunity to work in an area that is so dear to his heart and that he shared this love through this poignant book. I highly recommend it.  –Gail McPherson

 

As 2004 began The DaVinci Code cast a wide net that continued drawing readers into exploring books with religious themes.  With the release of The Passion of the Christ in late February, religious and spiritual topics became even more popular.  In recognition of that phenomenon, here are the most outstanding books with religious themes that I read during this year:

Pilgrim at Tinker Creek Annie Dillard

Abraham, a Journey to the Heart of Three Faiths Bruce Feiler

Mary called Magdalene Margaret George

Jesus in America Richard Wightman Fox

Peace Like a River Leif Enger

History of God Karen Armstrong

The Life You Save May be Your Own Paul Elie

Walking a Literary Labyrinth Nancy Malone

Gilead Marilynne Robinson 

Thanks for offering readers this wonderful forum for exchanging reading lists.  Sincerely, Mae Mallory Krulak     Baltimore, Maryland

 

Three best reads in 2004:

First, Mark Doty’s Still Life with Oysters and Lemon, several years old now, but since I reread it often I’m including it here.  This short work (or long essay) is a study in beauty and its kin, particularly loss and grief.  Beginning with a careful examination of a 17th century Dutch still life painting, Doty leads readers in considering what things are important and how we recognize them as being valuable.  From a discussion about the chemistry of pigment through the shattering loss of people, Doty’s skill as a poet (skill with language and with putting thought into it) makes me envious of his encyclopaedic reading, his insatiable curiosity, and his ability to describe.  This one is  perhaps the most important one book I’ve ever read and the one I never want to be without.

Second, Tim Gautreaux’ The Clearing startled me:  I’d never have picked it up except for a recommendation by a learned friend.  It is a novel set in a Louisiana cypress swamp early in the 20th century, a swamp being clear cut for lumber.  The plot is linear but intriguing, subplots abound and are more interesting: good versus evil is the major template, but the real questions are about the need for violence, about man’s place in his environment, about family, about, finally, what it means to be a person in a world we shape and are shaped by.

Third, Khaled Hosseini’s The Kite Runner came to me at Cheryl’s urging.  Nice title, great cover, but I would never have read it, the first Afghan novel written in English and beginning with children growing up in Kabul before the war.  Cheryl was evasive of my questions, finally just saying, “you need to read it.”  She was right.  This might be the best novel I’ve read in a decade or more; ultimately it deals with the possibility of redemption, what we all hope for, but it does so against a backdrop of beauty and horror, splendor and squalor,  riches and unimaginable poverty.  In some ways a study of parent-child relations, in some respects a book on culture and difference, in all respects written with skill and grace and spare but loaded language, The Kite Runner engaged me from the first paragraph, and I found myself being annoyed at anything that interrupted my reading.  Set in Afghanistan and America, this book left me breathless, reading fast to find what’s next, reading slowly to savor the exquisite writing, occasionally gasping out loud, coming  to understand why Cheryl couldn’t or wouldn’t answer my questions, and why she urged me to read it.

Worst read of the year: Tom Wolfe’s I am Charlotte Simmons.  If I make it through the last dozen or so pages, it will be the first TW I’ve finished since Bonfire of the Vanities.  And likely the last I’ll begin.  Think of Wolfe at his worst: 2-dimensional characters, a largely absent plot, and a sense of superiority in each of his caricatures/characters.  Double that and you get Charlotte Simmons.  Useful as a doorstop or flower press, not for reading.  TW does, however, have on a nice tie in the dust jacket photo.   –Donnie Nobles

 

The best book I read last year was "The Nightingales" by I can't recall who. 

Kate Goode, Austin, Texas

 

I just realized you said "worst" as well and I have just finished "I am Charlotte Simmons" by my favorite Tom Wolfe and it is the worst, without a doubt.  Which makes me sad.   Merry Christmas anyway-- Kate  

 

Hey y'all!  Thanks for the newsletter!  Of course, I'D appreciate if you suggested THE SWEET POTATO QUEENS' FIELD GUIDE TO MEN to your folks!  I'm in bad need of some more plastic surgery!  Hope y'all have a wonderful Christmas and a fantastic '05--Be Particular  -Jill Conner Browne, THE Sweet Potato Queen, Jackson, Mississippi

 

 

Hi; in your newsletter, you requested recommendations, so here's one.  I read "Darkly Dreaming Dexter" by Jeff Lindsay, in three hours.  I just couldn't put it down!!  -Mimi

 

My favorites that I read in 2004 (probably the same as many other responders)! 

Wild Swans by Jung Chang, Hell at the Breech by Tom Franklin, The Spirit Cacthes You and You Fall Down by Anne Fadiman, The Missing World by Margot Livesey, Three Junes by Julia Glass, Nickeled and Dimed by Barbara Ehrenreich, Ishmael by Daniel Quinn, The Weatherman by Clint McCown, The No.1 Ladies’ Detective Agency by Alexander McCall Smith, Pope Joan by Donna Woolfolk Cross, Eva Moves the Furniture by Margot Livesey, 1000 White Women by Jim Fergus   -Joyce Franz

 

My book of the year is Maisie Dobbs by Jacqueline Winspear.  I'm attaching my review of it, which you may use any way you like.  I hope you are open the week after Christmas, because I'll be in Montgomery then.  Martha D. Bone  

 

CONSTANT READER By Martha D. Bone

            Maisie Dobbs was nominated for both the Edgar and the Agatha—awards for mystery novels—in 2003, but it is much more than just a mystery.  It is one of those rare things: a whopping good story.

            Jacqueline Winspear, writer of Maisie Dobbs, was born in England and now lives in California.  She was raised in a small town in England, and states that her upbringing was almost Edwardian, and far removed from the modern world.  Maisie Dobbs is dedicated to the memory of Winspear’s grandparents.  Her grandfather, Jack Winspear, “sustained serious leg wounds during the Battle of the Somme in July 1916.”  Her grandmother, Clara Atterbury Clark, “was a munitions worker at Woolwich Arsenal.”  These dedications are important, because Maisie Dobbs is as much about the effects of the Great War on the English as it is about anything else.

            Not long ago, I pointed out to one of my daughters that Agatha Christie’s novels are full of widows and unmarried women.  The reason, of course, is that almost an entire generation of Englishmen was killed in World War I.  Christie was writing between the wars, and she was familiar with the scarcity of men.  Maisie Dobbs is a wonderful source for learning about what the first “modern” war meant, and the learning is a pleasure because of the wonderful story.

            Maisie Dobbs is age 13 in 1910.  Her mother has just died, and her father is a costermonger, a man who sells fruits and vegetables from a barrow or cart.  Maisie’s father is concerned about her because she is very smart, and he feels he cannot take proper care of her.  He finds her a place as a maid in a house in the high-rent district, working for Lord and Lady Compton.  Maisie is not just smart; she is brilliant.  Lady Compton discovers her reading Latin in the library and finds her a tutor.

            Maisie succeeds at her studies and attends Girton College of Cambridge University, where she can study but never get a diploma—she’s a woman, after all.  Maisie Dobbs describes a world where the classes are changing and moving, and the gender roles are changing also.  But Maisie takes some time off her studies to train as a nurse.  She is sent to work near the front in France.  The chapters about Maisie’s life at the front are fascinating—and surprising—reading.

            Maisie Dobbs is written in three parts.  In Part I we find Maisie setting up her own detective agency in 1929.  She is hired to find out if a man’s wife is cheating on him.  Maisie discovers a farm called The Retreat, where badly injured men can go to avoid the world.  Mysteries abound, and Maisie gets help from an old soldier in addition to her former tutor, Maurice, her father, and Lady Compton.

            Part II is a flashback which describes Maisie’s life from age 13 until she works as a nurse and falls in love with a doctor during the war.  Part II takes us back to the mystery of The Retreat.  I have the Penguin paper edition of Maisie Dobbs.  It has much interesting information about the book and the writer in a “Reader’s Guide.”  The Guide states: “With astonishing subtlety and sympathy, the novel relives the heroic struggles and devastating losses of those who strove and suffered in the so-called War to End All Wars.”

            Maisie Dobbs  is simply wonderful.  It is my discovery of the summer, perhaps of the year.  Read it to discover why women working in munitions factories were called canaries and what happened to Clara Clark’s eye.  Discover the other young women paired with Maisie, and find out how historic events affected their lives.  Discover what happened to Maisie and her doctor, and find out what Maisie learns about herself while she finds the answer to the mysteries in Maisie Dobbs. 

            If you like a good story, run right out and buy a copy of Maisie Dobbs by Jacqueline Winspear.  The second novel about Maisie Dobbs, Birds of a Feather, is on my desk, and it’s as good as the first.  As the New York Times Book Review said, “Be prepared to be astonished.”

 

My favorite reads:
I started off this year with The Five People You Meet In Heaven.  What a lovely book, filled with words that emulate warmth, laughter, compassion, and hope.  My other favorite read of the year is The Other Boleyn Girl.  It is the story of Anne Boleyn's younger sister, Mary, and her relationship with Henry VIII and his court (part fact, part fiction).  Fascinating.  (Good thing I wasn't born in that century -- I wouldn't have a head.)  In nonfiction, I recommend the book Woe Is I; it is extremely helpful in all things writing-related.  -- Su Ofe

 

Am blank at this moment...  Bob loved the Ben Franklin book (has his picture on the front - cannot recall the title) I liked The Desert Queen - story or Gertrude Bell - explains about current war situation in Iraq.  Am currently reading Angels and Demons, which I am really enjoying.  –Lynn Beshear

 

T/C/E,
Here is a short list of a few of my favorites for 2004:
The Tunnels of Cu Chi - excellent read that illustrates the
tenaciousness of the Viet Cong and the futility of our efforts to root
them out of a complex network of tunnels.
Personal Memoirs: Ulysses S. Grant - If you are a civil war buff this is
a must read.
Benjamin Franklin by Walter Isaacson - a great biography
John Paul Jones by Ivan Thomas - a great biography
Failure is not an Option by Gene Kranz - Excellent account of the space
program by the man who was mission controller for the Mercury, Gemini
and Apollo programs.
Flags of our Fathers: Heroes of Iwo Jima - great story of this epic battle
Flyboys by James Bradley - great WWII story
Ghost Soldiers: The Forgotten Epic Story of WWII Most Dramatic Mission
by Hampton Sides - Excellent story of the Battan Death Camp rescue
Night Fall by Nelson Demille - Fictionalized account of the events
surrounding the TWA Flight 800 crash
The Da Vinci Code by Dan Brown - Interesting and clever
Hell at the Breech by Tom Franklin - Great fiction, beautifully written

"Stiff: The Curious use of Human Cadavers" by Mary Roach ......very interesting and often funny account of how human cadavers have been used throughout history. Trust me - good book!  Hope this helps.....keep up the great work.  –Joe Panza

My favorite read of 2004 was an old read Pavilion of Women by Pearl S. Buck. The Birth of Venus, written by Sarah Dunant (newer, but maybe not published in 2004) was also good.   -Leah Slawson

 

The most fascinating book I read in 2004 was The Conversations by Michael Ondaatje with Walter Murch.  Novelist and poet Ondaatje (The English Patient, The Cinnamon Peeler) interviews Murch (The Godfather, Apocalypse Now, The English Patient, Cold Mountain) about his career as a film editor. After reading this book I realized how much film editing and poetry writing have in common. It was a revelation for me and actually changed how I view the process of revision of poems as well as how to teach poetry writing to my students at Spalding.  This is a book to savor and go back to – it has lots of visuals too, which makes it fun.  If you have a poet or film buff in the family, here’s your next birthday or Christmas gift!  -Jeanie Thompson

 

My favorite book of this year was -hands down -Seabiscuit  by Laura Hillenbrand.  I put off reading it for a long time thinking it was just for horse lovers, even though I kept hearing that it's not.  I watched the movie when it came on HBO, then I had to read the book.  It's a great story that will become a classic.   The author did such an impressive job of developing the characters that you would think she knew them all personally.  I didn't know until the end of the book that L.H. was suffering from Chronic Fatigue Syndrome while working on the book and was pretty much confined to her apt., doing all the interviews by phone and email.  That made it even more amazing.  A wonderful story from a gifted writer.  (Great movie, too!)
The Fred Factor by Mark Sanborn
This is an off the beaten path book that I read after receiving a high recommendation from a book club.  It has helped me to have a more positive outlook on life in general and toward work in particular.  A memorable book that I will read over again whenever I need an attitude adjustment!  -Scarlett Gamache

 

Have had 2 favorite books this year:  The Pleasure of My Company, by Steve Martin

and The Kite Runner by? set in Afgahanistan  -Lisa Parrish

 

"Freedom Writer: Virginia Foster Durr, Letters from the Civil Rights Era," edited by Patricia Sullivan, is on my list to recommend to our book discussion group for next year.

Anyone who knew Virginia Durr or wants to know more about her remarkable life should read this book, which tells what it was like being among the few liberals in Montgomery between 1951 and 1968.  She bemoans her unpopularity in the city in letters to a broad range of friends and acquaintances, such as Eleanor Roosevelt, Lyndon Johnson, Hugo Black, Jessica Mitford and many less famous contemporaries.  Life in Montgomery could be miserable, according to her own words, but the writer was exhilarated by signs of progress and many visitors. There also were escapes, such as attending Johnson's inauguration as "a guest of the family," and taking a trip to visit Linus and Ava Helen Pauling in California, followed by seeing Mitford. Durr wrote: "We were with them at their remote ranch in the Big Sur when he got word of the Nobel Peace Prize and that was really thrilling.... It was exciting at Decca's too when we got there as her book, as you know has been a terrific best seller much to her surprise and to mine too. She sold the paperback rights while we were there for $105,000, imagine!" The book was "The American Way of Death."  Durr lived much longer, but in 1965 she wrote, "I do get the feeling that no effort is ever wasted if you can just live long enough."  -Coke Ellington

 

Dear Cheryl and Thomas, My favorite read of 2004 has been Frank Stitt's cookbook.  I don't remember the title but you will know, as I bought so many.  They were for gifts which have already been wrapped and shipped.  I have not bought a copy of my own as I am hoping someone will give it to me for Christmas. Needless to say, I read one of the ones I was giving from cover to cover and it tops my list of favorite reads.  Love and best wishes for a very happy Christmas.  Bobbie Gamble, Greenville, AL.

 

Here's my contribution: By far, the best book I read this year was Peace Like a River by Leif Enger.  As much as I was drawn into the story of eleven-year-old Reuben Land who with his father and sister launched a cross-country search for older brother Davy, I was also drawn into the environment.  I've never been as cold as I was riding through North Dakota in a car with no heater, and there was so much oatmeal and coffee in the book, I found myself thinking of Reuben every morning at breakfast.  I also liked Eats, Shoots & Leaves, the punctuation expose, by Lynne Truss.    -Minnie Lamberth

 

Morning!  Per your request - some of my favorite books read in 2004:  The Preservationist by David Maine; Walking the Bible by Bruce S. Feiler; From Beirut to Jerusalem & Longitudes and Attitudes by Thomas Friedman; Eats, Shoots & Leaves by Lynne Truss; Father Joe  by Tony Hendra.  I love you column and it's always fun to find other good reads!  See you this afternoon.  -Gail Alsobrook

 

The Shadow of the Wind, by Carlos Ruiz Zafon—a literary thriller set in post-World War II Spain. The intrigue centers around a boy who falls in love with an author's work and sets out to discover more about the writer.  Bel Canto, by Ann Patchett—beautiful prose about a fictional hostage-taking in South America. The characters provide insight into the human condition (revealing ties that can bind such different people), through humor as well as tragedy.  Eats, Shoots & Leaves: The Zero Tolerance Approach to Punctuation, by Lynn Truss—if you're a perfectionist about writing, this book's for you! Her British wit actually reduced me to tears.  –Mildred Wakefield

 

Hi. I've got two possibilities -- mostly because each gave me and friends who'd read them lots to talk about.  1) THE LIFE OF PI. I know it's older, but I just got around to it this year.  2) THE RULE OF FOUR. A thinking person's antidote to Dan Brown (maybe it's a sendup of his pseudo-learned conspiracy-theory foofaraw). I guess I pick this one because it actually came out in 2004.  –Rick Anderson

 

The Enemy by Lee Child

Wiley's Shuffle by Lono Waiwaiole

Body of David Hayes by Ridley Pearson

America (The Book) by Jon Stewart

Peter and the Starcatchers by Dave Barry and Ridley Pearson

Don't Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus -Heidi Moos

 

Dear Cheryl & Thomas, 

O. K., I've been listening.  In response to your request for my favorite book or books of the year, I got carried away & now leave it to your editorial judgment as to what, if anything, you want to retrieve from the following effusion.  I intended at the outset to mention only the book dealt with in the final paragraph, but other books kept butting in.  

This year has been fiction catch-up time for me.  Beginning with his “DaVinci Code” and working back chronologically, I enjoyed all four of Dan Brown’s diverting capers. He employs the same basic pattern in each book -- a gruesome death in the opening paragraphs; a smart protagonist (male, female or both) challenged by a riddle involving technology or some other discipline, such as art history; stirs in a generous amount of travel; throws in a relentless, lethal pursuer; them astonishes you with the unveiling of a totally surprising villain.   

Interspersed among these were reading Carl Hiaasen’s “Skinny Dip,”an unexpectedly inventive, funny and happily indecent romp in the south Florida sun; listening to 16 of Patrick O’Brian’s magnificent set of 20 sea novels, beginning with “Master & Commander”; hearing Edith Wharton’s memorable Pulitzer winner, “The House of Mirth”; reading Bill Bryson’s “A Short History of Nearly Everything,” the single clearest and most comprehensive science book this layman has met; and relishing Warren St. John’s “Rammer Jammer Yellow Hammer,” a book to delight anyone, Northerner or Southerner, football fan or not, because it’s written by the finest writer to come out of Alabama since Tom Franklin. 

But my surprise of the year was Mark Haddon’s “The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time,” advertised as a detective story seen through the eyes of a 14-year-old autistic English boy.  It turns out to be funny, touching and above all, gripping.  Early on I realized I was reading a really sophisticated novel, whose characters and surroundings both are solid and real.  How Haddon, who previously has written only children’s books, could produce this striking novel for adults which will resonate in your mind for weeks is the biggest mystery of all.  Best wishes for the Holidays & beyond, -Tom Fitzpatrick

  • * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

 

"The Total View of Taftly"   Scott M.Morris  and "Welding With Children"     Tim Gautreaux  -Tim Stevens 

P.S.  I also should have added:  "The Heaven Of Mercury" and "Last Days Of The Dog Men" by Brad Watson

 

Good Morning Capitol Book and News,   I have thought long and hard about my favorite books for the year. At the risk of neglecting something, I have selected the following: 

Fiction -- The Enemy by Lee Child   I started reading Child's books in Australia, and I have read all of the books in the Jack Reacher series. While the series didn't start out all that auspiciously (but enough so to pique my curiosity), Child has recovered nicely. This book was a lot of fun to read.  Non-fiction -- The Devil in the White City -- Erik Larson (it may be The Devil and the White City, I can't find it on my shelf to verify)  I think this book was published in 2003 or 2002, but I didn't get to it until this past Spring. I thought it was a fascinating story that was told very well.  

Hope y'all have a nice day.  -Adam Hill

 

Hello!

Once again, it's been an interesting year for your newsletter, which I always enjoy reading!  Thanks for all the work that ya'll put into them!

Best Reads Of 2004,

1. Middlesex, by Jeffrey Eugenides......wonderful tale, very rich and deep writing, I enjoyed this one so much, that after reading it in January, I'm rereading it now

2. I Love You Like A Tomato, by Marie Giordano......great coming of age story, post WW2, of a young girl from Italy named Chi Chi

3. A Redbird Christmas, by Fannie Flagg.......this woman can just "write NO wrong!", all of her books are so very wonderful, and this one had me saying "awwww" aloud at the end of every chapter.  I will never see a redbird in my life again, without thinking of this heart-warming book.  Thanks, and a wonderful New Year to all of you there!  -Laura Thornton 

 

For best reads of the year, I would nominate three of Gregory Maguire's books: Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West; Confessions of an Ugly Stepsister; and Mirror, Mirror. These are all very imaginative and strange stories taking place in the distant shadowy past, told in beautiful language and built around well-known childhood tales. However, I don't recommend his book Lost, which takes place in the present although it contains some ghosts and possible ghosts. But, alas, it is tedious, too jumbled up and not beautifully written.  Happy New Year!  -Elaine Fuller

 

City of Light by Lauren Belfer was one of my favorite reads of 2004.  In 1901, Buffalo, N.Y. is one of the most preeminent cities in the U.S.  Louisa Barrett, the headmistress of a fashionable girls’ school, in the narrator of this novel of murder, mystery and intrigue.  Fascinating information about the political, economic and social history of Buffalo, as well as the development of hydroelectric power plants near Niagara Falls forms a rich background for the plot of this book.  It is one of those rare works of fiction that educates and entertains.  I also enjoyed Life of Pi, by Yann Martel, a novel about a boy and a tiger marooned in a boat in the middle of the ocean and how they manage to survive both physically and emotionally.  Great surprise ending!  For fun, light reading, I always like the Duncan Kincaid/Gemma James mystery series by Deborah Crombie and Alexander McCall Smith’s series about the #1 Ladies Detective Agency.  –Jean Smyth

 

 

Gary & Peggy’s Favorite Reads (some just Peggy’s, some Gary’s and some both)

I will start by recommending "Tell No One" and "Gone for Good" by Harlan Coben.  They are suspenseful, with endings you never expect.  A little less intense are these humorous, similar to "Murder She Wrote" mysteries, "Who Left That Body in the Rain?" and "Who Invited the Dead Man" by Patricia Sprinkle.    Carolyn Haines writes fun mystery books based in the Delta of Mississippi, revolving around "daddy's girls", with all her books having 'bones' in the title, like "Them Bones", "Crossed Bones", "Buried Bones".  "Redeeming Love" by Francine Rivers is a great fiction, based on the biblical story of Hosea.  It is definitely one of Peggy’s favorites. 

You can't go wrong with "Peachtree Road" by Anne Rivers Siddons.  If you prefer a little more suspense and violence, Ace Atkins "Leavin' Trunk Blues" and "Dark End of the Street" have a great character – Nick – who has exciting adventures around JoJo’s Blues Bar in New Orleans.  

Mike Stewart "Sins of the Brother", "A Clean Kill", "Dog Island" are similar adventures, but in and around South Alabama.  Gary is anxiously awaiting his new book coming in January.  

For a zany, off-the-wall humorous, with lots of drug action and violence, is Tim Dorsey “Cadillac Beach”, “Florida Road Kill”, “Stingray Shuffle”, “Triggerfish Twist”.  These involve a very, very interesting character, Serge Storms, and his escapades in South Florida.  –Gary & Peggy Carstens

 

A Redbird Christmas by Fannie Flagg.  Dear friends, I cannot tell you how much I have enjoyed this book.  What a wonderful Christmas story!  We have all know people like these characters in small towns and every now and then great things are theirs to do.  Especially recommend it for those who need a taste of home for the holidays or who need to look beyond themselves and their own troubles.  I don't think I will ever look at a redbird the same way again.  Bob Cly, Prattville  

 

My favorite book for 2004 is one that I just flipped through in the store and bought as a gift for someone else. As I sat down to wrap it I decided to read it -- well here it is Christmas Eve and it still isn't wrapped because everyone is having a ball reading it and looking at the pictures. (I actually feel a little guilty giving my daughter's boyfriend a slightly used book on Christmas.) "I am the cat, don't forget that" is for everyone, cat-lover or cat-hater. For those who like picture books, these are delightful photographs and you will recognize your cat in some of them. But the real kicker of this book are the poetic words of Roy Blount, Jr. (Was he a cat in a previous life?) The text will have you howling with laughter, and be sure to read the introduction. To be my favorite book of the year it has to touch me in someway. This one may not be "great literature," but it is funny, entertaining, and will lift your spirits -- what else can you ask from a book?
Hobbie Freehling

 

As usual, I am a few years late in reading what everyone else read while they were best sellers, but my thoughts are that only a few books are time sensitive, so it doesn’t matter when you read them. That said, my “best reads” may be ancient history to all the rest of your readers. Sue Monk Kidd’s “The Secret Life of Bees” is my top choice this year. It is such a wonderful little gem that I really look forward to reading something else by her. In a totally different vein is Dan Brown’s “Angels and Demons.” If you like fast paced page turners this one is great. I enjoyed it even more that “The DaVinci Code.” But I also like quieter slower paced books. For years my mother has recommended the Mitford series by Jan Karon, but I had not read them. Since I came across nearly all of them at the book sale that Capitol Book had to benefit the schools I bought them. I’ve read the first three and found them to be very light reading but with endearing characters. Two of my earlier favorites, “The Well Tempered Sentence” and “The Transitive Vampire” have been replaced by “Eats, Shoots & Leaves” by Lynne Truss. Not just anyone can make a book on punctuation a delightful read, but she has managed to write a book so entertaining that you would not even have to appreciate grammar to enjoy the book. Since the title echoes my sentiments I thought I’d really like Sara Nelson’s “So Many Books, So Little Time,” but have left it among the stack of unfinished ones. Since “Love in the Time of Cholera” and other books by Gabriel Garcia Marquez have been favorites, I decided to finally read my old dusty copy of his “One Hundred Years of Solitude.” Although lauded by many it may take me one hundred years to finish it. But I am enjoying reading his biography “Living to Tell the Tale.” It is especially interesting to see how little bits and pieces from events in his life became parts of his various books. Another book that had been on my shelf for awhile was Dennis Covington’s “Salvation on Sand Mountain” After reading his “Redneck Riviera” I went immediately to it. I don’t think many writers could have covered the subject in the way that he has, or could have imparted to those of us for whom the practice is all but abhorrent a sense of respect for these people. One of my frustrations and yet joys of reading is that one book and /or author leads you to another. The joy is that you never run out of next things to read, the frustration is that you don’t have enough time or that you find that you have to go back and read some things again. I bought “The Jane Austin Book Club” and while I’m sure it is a good book on its own, I put it down until I can read or reread some of the Austin books that it mentions so I will enjoy it more. In the Marquez biography, his comments on “Don Quixote” inspired me to buy a copy of it. “Moby Dick” sits on my shelf to be read again after reading “Ahab’s Wife” a few years ago. And then there are the favorite authors. I always enjoy books by Tom Robbins, so this year I read “Villa Incognito” and it did not disappoint. But on the other hand, Anne Tyler’s “The Amateur Marriage” was not one of my favorites this year. Amy Tan’s “The Opposite of Fate” was very good, but I prefer her novels. I continue to read novels by local or regional authors with interest. Of mention from this year’s list are Cassandra King’s “Making Waves” (first published as Making Waves in Zion) that I enjoyed even more than her “The Sunday Wife.” I look forward to her new book “Same Sweet Girls” especially since we were all in college at Montevallo at the same time. Nanci Kincaid was a new author for me. After reading “Verbena” I bought another of her books that I hope to read soon.

I can’t submit this list without including a book I just got for Christmas that while not a novel is a most fascinating book - Sabuda’s “America the Beautiful.” I collect pop-up books and Sabuda is a most remarkable paper engineer.  I know this is too long but I find so many books appealing - most are interesting for one reason or another - even when I don‘t like them. Perhaps I‘m just not selective enough, but it really is great to enjoy almost any book in some way or another. I guess it what it all boils down to is that my favorite book is the one I’m reading at the moment!  -Carol Hull

The best reads I found in 2004 were the Cape Light series of books by Thomas Kincaid.  Make sure to start with the first and read them in order.  He is a wonderful artist as well as author.  –Michelle Parks

 

 

I love anything by Jan Karon and John Grisham, Fannie Flagg...just finished reading "Shepherds Abiding"......Happy New Year to the Upchurches!!!  A friend......................

 

 

The Merrily Watkins Procedurals  by Phil Rickman.  These six  books, The Wine of Angels, Midwinter of the Spirit, A Crown of Lights, The Cure of Souls, The Lamp of the Wicked & The Prayer of the Night Shepherd follow  the career of Merrily Watkins,  single mom of a rebellious teen,  newly  ordained Anglican vicar, and as of  book two, official Diocese Deliverance Minister(new term for exorcist).  These books are hard to categorize - I would describe them as mysteries with a suggestion of the supernatural.  They are as much driven by the ever developing characters as by the plots.  These are probably my favorite find of the year. 

The Thursday Next series by Jasper Fforde.  The Eyre Affair, Lost in a Good Book, The Well of Lost Plots and Something Rotten are set in an alternative 1980's Great Britain.  The Crimean War has been going on for 130 years, time travel is routine - even regulated by the government, clone kits are for sale in every corner shop, and literature is a very serious business.  Literary Detective, Thursday Next, "book jumps" from one adventure to another as she attempts to foil great literary crimes such as the attempted kidnapping of Jane Eyre.  These books are hilarious and completely original.   

The Tales of the Otori trilogy by Lian Hearn.  Across the Nightingale Floor, Grass for His Pillow and Brilliance of the Moon.  Set in an imaginary country somewhat like feudal Japan, this trilogy chronicles the saga of Takeo as he changes from a simple village boy living among the "Hidden," a peace-loving people opposed to any violence, to warlord and leader of  his clan.  Not just a first-rate fantasy/adventure but a beautiful story of self-discovery.  The writing is lovely and lyrical - this is a terrific page turner. 

Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell by Susanna Clarke 

The Secret Life of Bees by Sue Monk Kidd.  I'm the only person in America who had not read this fantastic book so I don't need to give a description. 

More Than You Know by Beth Gutcheon.  A great book to read around Halloween.  This is a truely creepy ghost tale combined with parallel love stories set off by lovely writing. 

NonFiction: 

Tender at the Bone: Growing Up at the Table and Comfort Me With Apples More Adventures at the Table by Ruth Reichl.  Now Gourmet magazine editor, Ruth Reichl, writes about her life long love of food and cooking in these two very funny and touching books.  Her initial interest in food was "motivated by fear of her mother's (Queen of the Mold) cooking."  We follow her career as her initial interest turns to passion and she moves from cook to chef to food writer.  Along the way she meets such culinary luminaries as Wolfgang Puck, M.F.K. Fisher and Alice Waters.   

Imagined London: A Tour of the World's Greatest Fictional City Anna Quindlen.  From Bloomsbury to Baker Street to the London of P.D. James, Anna Quindlen gives readers a charming literary map (both real and purely fictional) of London

Without Reservations: The Travels of an Independent Woman by Alice Steinbach.  Pulitzer Prize winning writer, Alice Steinbach, quits her newspaper job and spends a year wandering around Europe.   

The Gourmet Cookbook and The Mitford Cookbook

 

Young Adult and Children's Lit: 

A Girl of the Limberlost by Gene Stratton-Potter.  A  classic I missed as a child.  Elnora Comstock lives in the Limberlost swamp.  She collects moths to pay for her education.  A beautiful book!!! 

A Great and Terrible Beauty by Libba Bray.  One of those great children's novels where a young girl is sent away to an English boarding school and, of course, all sorts of strange events take place.  The first of a proposed trilogy.   

Room 13, Moondog and Tartabull's Throw by Henry Garfield.  Spooky yet thoughtful books involving ghosts and a reluctant werewolf named Moondog.    

The Golden Compass Series by Phillip Pullman.  Definitely not just for children.

 Norman Tuttle on the Last Frontier by Tom Bodett

 

Favorites I Reread Every Year: 

Cheaper by the Dozen 

Onions in the Stew - Betty MacDonald 

The Children of Greene Knowe series by L.M. Boston.  This is one of the most wonderful children’s' series I have read.   

The Anne of Green Gables series 

James Herriot's books 

Thanks for all of your great reading suggestions!!!!  Nanne Cutler, Dothan, AL

 

My favorite book for 2004 is Cold Mountain by Charles Frazier.  It was the most romantic yet heart wrenching book I have ever read.  The characters showed undying love for one another after a short, fairly detached and always chaperoned acquaintance.  The setting is one I have fantasized for myself: beautiful farm, animals to care for, crops to raise and prepare for months again.  Close friendships with neighbors who would do anything for each other.  And then the intensity of the love that Ada and Inman share, for the most part, in letters over years of agony and waiting to be together.  They never doubted they would see each other again and their reunion - ah, what can you say?  I never felt such emotion in any other book I've read yet.   –Susan Kinner

 

From Bill Krulak, a retired Marine who’s now rector of an Episcopal church in north Baltimore, here’s my eclectic reading list of the best books I’ve enjoyed in 2004:

 

Peace Like a River  Leif Enger

The First Christian   Paul F. M Zahl (former dean of Birmingham’s Episcopal cathedral)

Dark Voyage + anything else by Alan Furst

Don Quixote Cervantes’ novel in Edith Grossman’s new translation

The Kite Runner   Khaled Hosseini

Any book by John Sandford, author of “Prey” series   -Bill Krulak, Baltmore. MD

 

OK, your pleas finally got to me, and I decided to list my favorite books from this past year.  They may or may not be 2004 editions, but I read them this year.  I don't have time to do more than a list, but here goes:

 

My number one favorite of the year was

Eventide by Kent Haruf, followed closely by 

An Unfinished Life by Mark Spragg.  Other favorites were:

Monkeewrench by P.J. Tracy

Time Traveler's Wife by Audrey Niffenegger

My Sister's Keeper by Jodi Picoult

Mrs. Kimble by Jennifer Haigh

Loud and Clear by Anna Quindlen

Marriage: A Duet by (I love everything Lee Child writes!) 

I read lots of other good books and some that were so-so, but these were my favorites.  I look forward to reading your final list from everyone!  -Ann Boles

 

FOR THE WRITTEN RECORD:
I re-read two books in 2004 which have been, and still are, two of my all-time favorites: 
1.  The End of the Affair, by Graham Greene, which is not only a good story but also a nuanced theological reflection on two subjects:  (a) Baptism and (b) the relationship between faith and healing.  Its picture of life during the London blitz shows vividly the fear, sadness, and recklessness exhibited by people who lived through that experience.  
2.  Crossing to Safety, by Wallace Stegner, which is a beautifully written and insightful story about friendship, marriage, and the nature of the professional academic life. 
Happy New Year!!   -Cam West

 

You asked for a favorite book of the year - you have probably already been told this many times.  Fannie Flagg's "A Redbird Christmas" was just fantastic!  I cried and smiled at the same time. 

-Michelle Condon

 

My Favorite Reads of 2004
    I think the best book I read all year was Middlesex  by Jeffrey Eugenides. It deals with a provocative subject and handles it well. And the title is perfect.
    A book I would not have found except through my book club, and one that I'm so glad I read, is The Question of God by Armand Nicholl. The author, who is dean of the school of religious studies at Harvard, delivers an imaginary debate between Sigmund Freud and C.S. Lewis on whether or not there is a God. It's fascinating.
    On a sort of similar subject, A Travel Guide to Heaven, by Anthony De Stefano, so enchanted me that I've bought several copies for gifts. As one of the "praise-fors" on the back says, "This book makes you feel that heaven is even more wonderful than we had ever hoped. I applaud the author for his exquisite imagination. . . ." It's definitely a book to make you feel better if you've got the blues.
    This year I discovered Elizabeth George, and it's like opening a box of candy. When you finish one, you just want more. Just since September, I've consumed A Great Deliverance, A Place of Hiding, and For the Sake of Elena. Next up is In Pursuit of a Proper Sinner.
    
Another book worth mentioning is A Thousand Days in Venice, by Marlena de Blasi. It could be compared to Under the Tuscan Sun, in that it's a true story of a woman who moves to Venice with a new love and gets into the business of restoring an historic building--in this case, an apartment rather than a whole villa. My dream is to spend several weeks living in Venice, so this book was a delight.
    I finally read The Chronicles of Narnia this fall. It was the book I took to the hospital when I had a hip replacement, figuring that having a heavy dose of anesthesia in my system would not necessarily be an impediment when reading a fantasy intended for young readers. I found that I loved the characters, the adventures they had, the implied spiritual lessons. I eagerly anticipate the movie of The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe, which I understand will be ready in 2006. It was interesting that many of the people who came in and out of my hospital room, including my surgeon, recognized Narnia from their youth and remembered it with fondness.
    Then there was Hell at the Breech, by Tom Franklin, and The Lovely Bones, by Alice Sebold. Or were they in 2003? I'm sure there are many other fine reads from 2004 that I'm not remembering--but I can blame the anesthesia for that!   -Sunshine Huff

 

My favorite book of the year was KILLING THE BUDDHA: A Heretic's Bible,
edited by Peter Manseau and Jeff Sharlett. For readers who haven't heard of
the book, the editors asked thirteen contemporary authors to retell biblical
stories. The editors spent a year traveling around America (and several of
our state's small towns have cameos) discussing the state of religion and
spirituality in this country. The resulting book is thought-provoking and
fascinating. The editors and authors remind humans that recognizing and
acknowledging faith is much more complicated than it seems. It's a book I
expect to reread repeatedly.  -Pam Kingsbury, Florence, Alabama

 

Okay....favorite read....Zippy by Haven Kimmel or A Girl
Named Zippy (something like that)
It's  disarmingly funny & poignant. Great escapist reading.
I read it while my mom was in the hospital. It was my
"getaway". I couldn't wait to find out what Zippy (the
author the 5 year old protagonist) was getting into &
finding out about life & her loving, if somewhat strange
(aren't they all) family. It's a good "get rid of the
winter doldrums" read… It must be true. They said it on NPR
a couple of weeks ago.  –Gabrielle Darch

 

I haven't read any reviews on this book, so I don't know what other people think, but my favorite was The Enormous Arrival by Sally Poole. Don't let the cover (Confederate flag) scare you away. The story is about a girl of mixed race and her struggles to make herself a success in a man's world in the South. This is a sweet story that southerners will enjoy. I also liked Cassandra King's Making Waves and The Sunday Wife. I just finished Fannie Flagg's A Redbird Christmas. Another good southern story!   -Camille Brignac, Selma.

 

Book Report

Shadow Divers 

Robert Kurson

Microsoft Word format  -Tom Smedley

 

Hell at the Breech by Tom Franklin did not come out this year, but I read it this year. My opinion is it is not only the best book I read last year, but also the best book I have read in a long time. I was so impressed with the book that I bought it for an Australian friend of mine hoping to give him a keyhole view into southern psyche. He loved the book and is still talking about the character, Billy. I understand how he feels. The characters kept pulling at me. For months after finishing the book, Tim and I would sit and muse at casting the movie. Having made these positive statements, I will admit to feeling it started a tad dark for my taste; in fact, I almost quit reading. But Tim encouraged me to continue and I am very glad I did. The characters are dirt real and hard scrabble believable. Even the ones you love to hate have their own story lines that made me, as a reader, interested in them enough to want to know what was going to happen—and kept me guessing as to their fate.  The setting easily qualifies for rural gothic with an uncomfortable familiarity. The plot intrigues but is not overly complicated—and that due to Tom’s skill as there are many story lines and time shifts.

One last note-- I know everyone believes that Cold Mountain is the quintessential new southern novel. But my vote goes to Hell at the Breech for lots of reason but the main one is this: By God, Tom sees to it that the villain gets his due!  -Karren Pell

 

The past year has been another good one for reading. Of course, I don't think I've ever been through a bad year for reading -- except perhaps when I was grad school about 15 years ago and had to read so much for classes that I pretty much stopped reading for fun.  Top honors go to "In the Presence of the Enemy" by Elizabeth George, a real page turner in the Inspector Lynley/Barbara Havers series; "The Amazing Maurice and His Educated Rodents" by Terry Pratchett; Neil Gaiman's "Neverwhere"; and "The Well of Lost Plots" and "Something Rotten" by Jasper Fforde. "In the Presence of the Enemy," which starts off with the kidnapping of a little girl was the result of an affair between a conservative MP and a liberal newspaperman, is great as a work of suspense and mystery has multiple levels -- the main story, things that are going on the regular characters lives, etc. The version on PBS had to be diluted like crazy to fit in one episode of "Mystery" and doesn't begin to do justice to the book. "The Amazing Maurice ..." is being marketed as a children's book but is fun for people of all ages and doesn't require prior knowledge of Pratchett's  "Discworld" series although the action takes place on Discworld. (Not that it has anything to do with this book, but Discworld is a world, sort of like our own, that is a giant disc resting on four elephants who are standing on the back of giant turtle that is swimming through space.)This book, a Pratchett jump-off from the Pied Piper story, focuses on a talking cat named Maurice and a bunch of talking rats that team up with a boy with a pipe to con various villages. The rats invade the town, the boy with pipe provides his services to the villagers by drawing them out with his pipe, and the rats, cat and boy meet up on the other side of town to split the proceeds. Things go terribly wrong, however, when the gang tries this scam in the decidedly creepy town of Bad Blintz."Neverwhere" is a suspenseful fantasy set in London's underworld, not a crime syndicate but the Tube stations, trains and sewers. Unbeknownst to most people above ground, there's a complex society underground, and a man who tries to help an injured girl he finds on the sidewalk gets swept into it.And well, I'm a Jasper Fforde fan to the core and loved the two latest entries in the saga of Thursday Next. There also were some great updates to the www.jasperfforde.com Web site this year -- the Seven Wonders of Swindon page and the test for prospective Hamlets both are a hoot. Other great books for the year include several related to Cuba that I read because my mom and I participated in a Jewish humanitarian mission to Havana in March. "Trading with the Enemy: A Yankee Travels Through Castro's Cuba" by Tom Miller and "Traveler's Tales Cuba," edited by Tom Miller, both bring Cuba and its people to life. "Cuba Diaries: An American Housewife in Havana" by Isadora Tattlin, a pen name for an American woman who lived in Havana for a few years while her European husband was working for a European company doing business there, also was a lot of fun to read and interesting. Still other greats are "Deception on His Mind," an Elizabeth George book that makes Barbara Havers the protagonist in a case in which she gets involved in investigating the death of Pakistani man associated with the family of her Pakistani neighbors" and Terry Pratchett's "Going Postal," another Discworld novel that does not require prior Discworld background.   –Madelyn Dinnerstein, Pittsburgh, PA

I have a confession to make: I'm moderately obsessed with Elizabeth George mysteries and it's all Cheryl and Eleanor's fault. I read them like I eat Doritos--one after the other until the bag is empty. I've even resorted to buying mass market paperbacks. Ugh! But I love every guilty minute of them. Now, my literary sensibilities were satisfied by my real favorite read of 2004, _The Shadow of the Wind_ by Carlos Ruiz Zafon (with an accent over the O). It is a literary suspense novel in the vein of Arturo Perez Reverte (accent again) and Umberto Eco. Translated from the Spanish and set in Barcelona, the language is lyrical and transports you to one of the loveliest cities in Europe. The story is the tantalizing coming-of-age of Daniel, the son of an antiquarian bookseller, and his search for the elusive author of _The Shadow of the Wind_, a novel chosen by Daniel (or FOR him?) from the Cemetery of Forgotten Books. There is wry humor, just the right amount of romance, satirical politics--everything necessary to elevate it from mere mystery to literature worth buying in hardback and keeping forever. And thanks to my very special local independent, I have a signed first edition! Life doesn't get any better.  Happy New Year and thanks for being there.  –Ashley Gordon, Auburn, AL

 

My hands down favorites for 2004, not very original perhaps, but here they
are: Kite Runner, and Reading Lolita in Teheran. Reading Lolita motivated
me to actually READ the Nabokov book that inspired the title. I probably
appreciated that great work more profoundly than I would have as a younger
reader. "Reading Lolita" was the second book I've read with a pencil in
hand, underlining all the important bits. The message is one that spoke to
all that I love: that the themes of great literature are a common
denominator that can speak to the humanity in all of us, no matter how
divided we are by our politics. "Kite Runner" is another must read......a
powerful look at class and loyalty, honor and integrity, and compelling
prose that draws you in from the first sentence. In both books, the
parallels between the fundamentalism and dogmatism of Iran and Afghanistan
and what is happening with rise of the same in our own great country should
be a warning to us all about what happens when the lines between religion
and state begin to blur.  –Alice Wertheim, Atlanta, GA

 

My favorite read of 2004 wasn’t published in either this century or the last! Jerome K. Jerome’s hysterically funny Three Men in A Boat: To Say Nothing of the Dog! was first published in 1889. It is side-splittingly hilarious with wonderful authorial asides, including the initial explanation of why the titular three men (and the dog) took to a boat. The description later in the novel of how Uncle Podger hung a picture in his home is equally if not more comic, not least because it rings so of real life.

My second favorite read of the past year was The Assassin’s Cloak: An Anthology of the World’s Greatest Diarists edited by Irene and Alan Taylor. Spanning four centuries, there are several entries for each day of the year by such diarists as Samuel Pepys, Virginia Woolf, Katherine Mansfield, Barbara Pym, and Noel Coward. The title comes from an entry by William Soutar: “A diary is an assassin’s cloak which we wear when we stab a comrade in the back with a pen.”  Speaking of Barbara Pym, I have started reading her wonderful books in which I have found a balance of the comic, gently satirical novels of Angela Thirkell (another mid-20th century writer well worth reading) and the more somber, introspective novels of contemporary British author (and another favorite of mine) Anita Brookner.  –Tess Ware

 

 

If it's not too late, I'll contribute to the "best book" for 2004 I have read:

Life of Pi by Yann Martel, winner of the Man Booker Prize and published in 2001 I believe, so not a new book.  We used this book at Huntingdon this fall for our First-Year Experience 101 course, a course required of all first-year students.  I may be in the minority in my liking of this book, none of my students did saying they had problems with the book's structure and they couldn't relate to the Pi the protagonist, and a number of the other instructors I spoke with were less than impressed, but I had a different reaction.  And I think it is because I could relate to Pi very easily.  For those who haven't read the book, the majority of the text is relating Pi's survival in a life boat after the ship he and his family were on sinks on their way from India to Canada where they are relocating.  His father had been a zookeeper, so on the ship were some of the animals from the zoo.  While several make it into the lifeboat with Pi, only Richard Parker - a bengal tiger - survives past a few days, so here is Pi in a lifeboat with a bengal tiger.  However, I think for me the most poignant part of the novel occurs before the ship catastrophe.  Pi in his childhood begins to explore religion and finds that there are aspects of several faiths to which he is drawn.  This causes a lot of consternation for his parents and area clergy, who were unaware that while he was visiting their house of worship, he was also visiting others.  Pi causes a lot of discussion when he asks to be baptized and for a prayer rug.  In trying to explain himself he simply states, "I just want to love God."  Here's a brief excerpt from the book (pg. 73)  that for me is quite profound:

 

Pi's mother: " ... Listen, my darling, if you're going to be religious, you must be either a Hindu, a Christian or a Muslim ...."

 

Pi: "I don't see why I can't be all three.  Mamaji has two passports.  He's Indian and French.  Why can't I be a Hindu, a Christian and a Muslim?"

 

Pi's mother: "That's different.  France and India are nations on earth."

 

Pi: "How many nations are there in the sky?"

 

Pi's mother: She thought for a second. "One.  That's the point.  One nation, one passport."

 

Pi: "One nation in the sky?"

 

Pi's mother: "Yes.  Or none.  There's that option too, you know.  These are terribly old-fashioned things you've taken to."

 

Pi: "If there's only one nation in the sky, shouldn't all passports be valid for it?"

 

Pi's mother: A cloud of uncertainty came over her face.

 

Pi:  "Bapu Gandhi said --"

 

Pi's mother: "Yes, I know what Bapu Gandhi said."  She brought a hand to her forehead.  She had a weary look, Mother did. "Good grief," she said.

 

What's the saying about out of the mouths of babes .... In considering all our problems in this country and the world brought about by religious bickering, maybe Pi is on to something here.

 

-Eric A. Kidwell

 

Here's my column.  Use as you like:

CONSTANT READER

By Martha D. Bone

            At the end of the year, I usually give a list of the ten best books reviewed in this column.   But 2004 wasn’t a great reading year.  There have been many good books, but few great books.  Consequently, for 2004 I have decided to give the best book in each genre or kind.

            For fiction, there is just no question.  Maisie Dobbs is the best novel I have read in several years, not just 2004.  It was nominated for two mystery novel awards, but it is much more than just a mystery.  It is one of those rare things: a whopping good story.

            Maisie Dobbs is the story of a young woman who becomes a maid in London at age 13 in 1910.  Maisie is not just smart; she is brilliant.  Lady Compton discovers her reading Latin in the library and finds her a tutor.  From there, Maisie goes on to Cambridge University, where she can study but never get a diploma—she’s a woman, after all.  Then Maisie leaves the university to become a nurse during the First World War.  We see her serving at the front, and then in her life as a detective after the war.

            This novel is simply astonishing.  Readers will learn much about historic events of the time, always told in personal terms.  But the best thing is the wonderful story.  I am using Maisie Dobbs in my composition classes this spring because we all write better when we read wonderful writing, and this book is full of simply wonderful writing.  Maisie Dobbs is available in paperback, and the second novel about Maisie, Birds of a Feather, is available in hardback.  It is almost as good as Maisie Dobbs.

            The nonfiction book is also a runaway: Shadow Divers by Robert Kurson.  Shadow Divers is a true account of two deep-water divers who discovered and identified the wreck of a German U-boat off the coast of New Jersey.  No one knew that a U-boat had wrecked in that location.  John Chatterton and Richie Kohler were the two primary divers who found U-896 in 1991, 230 feet below the surface of the Atlantic.  I wrote, and still believe, that this is an absolute wow of a book.  I gave two copies of this book as Christmas gifts.  One of the recipients has already finished it, and he says “Wow!” too.

            Shadow Divers is part history, part adventure, and part biography.  Bill Nagle took Chatterton on his first dive to the U-boat wreck, and they were stunned to discover a submarine.   Subsequent dives revealed that the crew was still aboard, the remains of 56 men.  There were no government records of a U-boat sunk anywhere near the wreck location.  No historian ever wrote of such a boat.  No expert had a clue that a U-boat had ever been just there, so close to the New Jersey coast.

            Although Kohler and Chatterton were only high school graduates, the two did research about U-boats that is worthy of any doctoral candidate.  They even took trips to Germany and interviewed relatives of the men who died aboard the U-boat.

            Perhaps the most impressive thing about Shadow Divers is the determination and courage described by Kurson.  Chatterton and Kohler were not the only divers on U-869.  Three men died while diving on the wreck.  A father and son diving pair both died on their first dive to I-869.  But Chatterton and Kohler went back again and again.  Kurson’s descriptions of the last two dives which finally proved that the wreck was U-869 were so suspenseful and hair-raising that I actually had to get up and pace around for a bit before I could continue reading.

            Shadow Divers has much more information, many pictures, biographies of many men, other exciting diving adventures, and much more history.  Every single page of this book is fascinating.  It is a superb book.

            The memoir of the year is Alexandra Fuller’s tragic, funny story of her childhood in sub-Sahara Africa.  In Don’t Let’s Go to the Dogs, we get much enchantment and horror, but we also get a wide picture of the political turmoil in Africa.  Alexandra was called Bobo, and she lived in a changing Africa.  Even the names of the places changed—Rhodesia to Zimbabwe, Salisbury to Harare.  The borders separating countries moved almost weekly, and someone was always trying to kill the white Africans who believed they owned their land in Africa.  Of course, black Africans were being killed by white Africans and by one another.  Safety wasn’t even possible.  If a political foe didn’t kill one, the snakes and bugs and beasts could have a go.

            Bobo was born in England, but the Fullers moved to Africa when she was three.  Bobo has one sister, Vanessa, but the Fullers lost three children: Adrian, Olivia, and Richard.  The strongest portrait in this memoir is of Mum, and I can’t imagine anyone who could read this book and not ache for her and Dad.

            The Fullers were racists who cared for the black Africans who came to their door for medical attention.  They were excellent farmers, and Mrs. Fuller took care of many dogs, some of them left to die by settlers moving away.  They were also marathon drinkers.  Mr. Fuller had to be extinguished by a guest when he set himself on fire at Bobo’s wedding.

            Their kindness and essential goodness saves the Fullers, as does their hard work and their courage.  I laughed out loud at parts of Don’t Let’s Go to the Dogs, and I actually sobbed at other parts.  But I didn’t want to stop reading this marvelous book.

            The last book is a children’s book.  Art Spiegelman is the writer and illustrator of Open Me…I’m a Dog!  This book (or dog) is the story of a dog who meets a witch who smells like oatmeal.  At first they get along, but then the reader is warned: “Try not o be around witches when they get mad.”  The dog is turned into something else, but I won’t ruin the story for you.  He meets Magda, the magical maiden of a mountain.  Magda has a temper tantrum and turns him into something else.  Then he meets an evil wizard who turns him into—you guessed it—a book.  But the dog/book has much to say and many appeals to make to the reader.

            Spiegelman is a rather famous cartoonist who won the Pulitzer Prize for Maus, the three-book story of a mouse who lived in Nazi Europe.  He is also the author of In the Shadow of No Towers, a sad and wonderful book for adults.  Open Me…I’m a Dog!  has simply fabulous illustrations, and there is a leash hooked to the spine of the book.  It is delightful for both children and adults.

            There are the biggies for 2004.  If we get cold weather again, we will all get some good reading time.  There’s nothing like it—wrap up in a warm blanket, light the fire, make some hot chocolate, and read.  Heaven!  -Martha Bone, Maysville, KY

 

If it’s not too late, here’s some suggestions for your book list:  A friend suggested Cape Refuge by Terri Blackstone  I liked Angles and Demons & Da Vinci Code by Dan Brown – Please remember that it is FICTION. – I do like that it has gotten numerous people to start talking about religion and its meaning to them though.  (BTW – On my trip to Italy in Nov., I saw numerous people reading both of them.)  The Pat Conroy Cookbook by Pat Conroy (Especially the autographed one that my son and daughter law got from y’all as a gift for me.) 

Frank Stitt’s Southern Table: Recipes and Gracious Traditions from Highlands Bar and Grill (The autographed ones that I purchased from y’all and gave as Christmas gifts and the one that I kept for myself have been thoroughly enjoyed.)  Carolyn 101 – By Donald Trump’s right hand person on The Apprentice.   Light, interesting reading about a female making it to the top.

 

I’m sure that there are many more that I’ve purchased there but these are the ones that come to mind first.  Have a good one, -Deborah Green

 

My favorite book of 2004 was Little Women. I liked it because when I
read it I felt comfortable and cozy, like everything was going to be
alright. I loved the characters' different range of personalities,
especially Jo's. I also liked the fact that you couldn't predict what was
going to happen and everything was surprising. It made me proud to see the
four children grow up, even though one met her end early, and go to
different husbands and lifestyles, like I was their mother. The book
inspired me to do good things and to be nicer to my little sister.  –Summer Upchurch

 

One of my favorite books this year was To Say Nothing of the Dog by Connie Willis.  It is a time traveling journey with the hero shuttling between the 21st century and 1940s England.  Every paragraph is crammed with both literary and historical allusions, wordplay as only the British can do it and enough dry wit to float Jerome K. Jerome's Three Men in a Boat.  A favorite character has to be the indomitable British woman who dreams up the jumble sale, forerunner to every church bazaar since.  -Sarah Robinson

 

As usual, I forgot one.  Please add to my list "Kindred" by Octavia Butler. It's about a black woman living in California in 1976 who keeps getting mysteriously transported to the Maryland plantation where her ancestors were a slave and the son of the owner. The descriptions of life on the plantation are amazing, the characters are wonderful and the book makes you think.  -Madelyn Dinnerstein, Pittsburgh, PA

 

Late entry on best reads:  Techinically it doesn't really count since I just read it, but I have to put in a word for Cassandra King's "The Same Sweet Girls." At the head of my first list was Sue Monk Kid's book, so when I saw her endorsement on the book cover I was even more eager to read the book. At first I had difficulty getting into the book because I was trying so hard to figure out which character represented which of the real SSG's, but later let go of that. The book is a joy to read. It makes you realize all over again how dear our long time friends are whether they be from our college days or not. And it would certainly make me long for such friendships were I not already blessed to have my own dear friends form college that I too have kept up with for 40 years now.  –Carol  Hull 

 

Wow! It sure is difficult picking the next book to read.

But these were my favorites of 2004: 

Light on Snow - Anita Shreve

The Last Sin Eater - Francine Rivers

The Wedding  - Nicholas Sparks

Until the Real Thing Comes Along - Elizabeth Berg

The Florabama Ladies' Auxiliary and Sewing Circle - Lois Battle

Bet Me - Jennifer Crusie

Once Upon A Wedding - Kathleen Eagle -Jackie Culpepper

 

Dear Capitol Book and News,  liked reading Life of Pi last year.  I thought it was original, and very well written.  Linda Thornbury

 

 

If you want to be “in the know” at all times, you should

subscribe to our email newsletter. Just click on the “email” link below,

and tell us to sign you up!

 

Need more info? Want to reserve a book? Here are the many ways you can contact us:

Capitol Book & News Company
 1140 E. Fairview Avenue Montgomery, AL 36106
 Voice 334-265-1473 | Fax 334-834-2405

 Email Us!
         Monday-Friday 9-5:30 | Saturday 10-4 | Closed Sunday
 

Capitol Book Home